Living Cultures 2024: The Next Steps
The Maasai Living Cultures Project is a collaboration between the Pitt Rivers Museum and Maasai community leaders. The project, which began in 2017, is funded by the Staples Trust, a Sainsbury family charitable trust. It is part of one strand of the Museum's ongoing work to build equitable relations with Indigenous Peoples whose material culture is represented in the Pitt Rivers collections.
In September 2024 a delegation from Kenya and Tanzania will be visiting the Pitt Rivers Museum as the next step in the Living Cultures Project. Members of the five families from whom the objects recognised as culturally sensitive were taken, will be visiting the Museum to reconnect with the objects and work with our team to identify possible next steps.
The family representatives were chosen as a result of lineage research conducted in 2022/203 to trace the families related to the objects. Where an object was worn by women, a female delegate was chosen, and likewise for the men. The delegation is led by two women, one from Tanzania and one from Kenya, to reflect the role of women as cultural custodians and the fact that women made all the artefacts in question. The family delegates will spend time with the objects, perform additional healing rituals and advise on their continued care in the Museum or possible return to the family. Different families may decide upon different outcomes.
This is the final step in the process of reconciliation and healing ceremonies with these five families. Together, we will be looking to create equitable partnerships, especially with regards to knowledge sharing about how to care for and present Maasai culture in the Museum, and to continue building a partnership based on respect, trust and deeper understanding.
The Visit
At the start of the week-long visit, Maasai delegates, museum staff and selected members of the Maasai diaspora were invited to participate in the welcoming ceremony, which had been set up in line with cultural guidance and support from Samwel Nangiria and Chief Laibon Oloiboni Mokompo Ole Simel. This emotional opening ceremony began with the making of a new fire to ceremonially bless all the participants.
This was the first time the delegation had seen all five objects, which were laid out, covered in blue cloth on trays at the front of the room. Each family member greeted their object, which had been identified during this process as being taken from their ancestral lineage. Seeing the ornaments, four of which have been in the Museum for over a century, the delegates later described how they felt strong physical reactions, as if they were about to faint or unable to breathe, hear or see.
The family members felt intense shock and sadness because seeing the objects reminded them of all the hurt and pain their families had endured in the last century. In Maasai conceptualisations, the taking of these sacred ornaments must have involved extreme violence and their absence will lead to devastating loss of life and land for the families in question. When an object like this is lost or stolen, the whole family will suffer greatly; children will be stillborn, cattle die and whole lineages can disappear. Although they knew that the objects were in the UK, having received updates from the project and photographs from the Museum, it had been almost inconceivable to them that this was real. Meeting the objects face-to-face after all this time provoked physical pain and stress, nightmares, faintness and loss of hearing and vision.
To help with this, and following cultural and spiritual advice, specially selected calming herbal teas were made, using the roots of plants harvested in the Loliondo sacred forest. These were ceremonially applied to the objects (in small quantities and as previously agreed with the PRM conservation team) and were then offered to the delegates, staff and participants. Delegates later said that one of the reasons they were able to withstand the hurt was dues to these herbal medicines of Oseki and Eluaai, commonly known as sandpaper-sauce berry and whistling thorn respectively. For the Maasai, the boiled and cooled preparation of Oseki brings feelings of happiness, manages stress levels and brings harmony to the environment (in this case, the Museum). The ceremonially prepared beverage of Eluaai brings clarity of vision, positive imagination and healing at both a personal and institutional level.
Opening speeches by Maasai Living Cultures project leader, Samwel Nangiria, PRM Director, Prof. Laura Van Broekhoven and PALCA representative, Ruth Sintamei, outlined the different steps in the process so far, building trust and new practice for all partners involved, all made possible thanks to the vital support of the Staples Trust. Sam and Ruth stressed the importance of cultural healing as one of peaceful unification and reconciliation for the whole Maa Nation, especially as the innovative conceptualisation of this process as one led by women, ensured it transformed into one of cultural revival and healing. Among the Maasai, cultural knowledge in the form of language, cultural traditions of making and meaning-giving is often transferred by mothers but for too long, women's crucial contributions to this knowledge-transfer have been unacknowledged and underrepresented. This women-led delegation is, therefore, seen as one of hope and liberation.
The Outcome
After a week of deliberations, the Maasai family delegates, who had been specifically selected as cultural knowledge keepers by their families, made the decision that the objects should remain in the care of the Pitt Rivers Museum. They felt that it was clear that the objects were being well cared for. This decision was reached after much discussion and deliberation and following advice from Mokompo. From a Maasai perspective, these hereditary objects would never be given away or sold (they can only be lent to family members for a very short time) and therefore, they must have been taken by killing the owner and removing it from the body on the battlefield. The objects are considered as warriors and in Maasai tradition, when a warrior dies, they are not brought back home but are buried on the battlefield. Hence, the delegates decided that it would be appropriate, given that the objects are being well cared for, that they would best be kept in the care of the Museum. This was deemed comparable to a soldier, having been killed overseas, being buried in a Commonwealth cemetery.
Having reached this decision, more cultural provenance information was shared and each family member gave further cultural guidance on how they would like the Museum to care for their objects. Because we now know the names of the original owners of these ornaments and because these ornaments are considered to equate to the bodies of their owners, the families asked for each object to be kept in a separate box bearing the name of each owner. It was also agreed that the Maasai nation, families and individuals will have lifetime access to the five ornaments, which can be facilitated online.
The stories behind each object will also be documented and made available, in case anyone wants to learn more about the circumstances of separation and the process of healing. Interpretation materials in the form of booklets, video or audio can be made available in two languages - English and Maa, although it was flagged as a matter of urgent concern for the Maa nation, that many people, particularly women and girls, continue to lack the formal education to enable them to access this material.
The Legacy
The continued presence of these objects and the legacy of the Maa-led peaceful process of Osotua (relationship building in peace) represents a bond for life, as the ornaments, which are referred to as 'mothers and fathers', remain in the care of the Museum, as part of a process imbued with cultural healing and relationship building. Maasai representatives will work with the Museum on future collaborations to decide how the outcomes of this unique process and Maasai cultural traditions can be best represented in the permanent galleries of the Museum, so that as many visitors as possible will learn from this process.
What are the five culturally sensitive objects?
The objects identified as being culturally sensitive are:
1. Engononkoi Narok - A hereditary necklace of blue beads passed from father to son, a crucial element of initiation ceremonies. It should never be sold or given away. (Accession number: 1904.34.25) Collector: Alfred Claud Hollis
2. Emonyorit - Earring worn by young women after circumcision, reconfigured into a neck ornament after marriage. It would never stay permanently in this state. (Accession number: 1904.34.36) Collector: Alfred Claud Hollis
3. Orkatar/Orkataar - Hereditary bracelet passed from father to son, which should never be sold or given away. (Accession number: 1904.34.38.1-2) Collector: Alfred Claud Hollis
4. Isikira - Head ornament worn by newly circumcised girls. It can only be used by one specific person and would always be dismantled after use. It can never be borrowed, sold or given away. (Accession number: 1927.84.51) Collector: Rev.William Ernest Taylor
5. Isurutia - Hereditary woman's arm/neck ornament which represents the sacred bond of marriage. It can never be borrowed, sold or given away. (Accession number: 1996.21.77) Collector: Phoebe Somers
Delegates Visiting Oxford
- Samwel Nangiria Taresero - Project lead and Director of the Ngorongoro NGO Network
- Ruth Sintamei Tuleto - Project support and PALCA (Pan African Living Cultures Alliance) representative
- Eve Yiamoi Merin - Orkiaama representative Kenya
- Alice Tipap - Orkiaama representative Tanzania
- Abrahamu Yohana Laizer - Maasai videographer Oltoilo le Maa
- Noomutaitin Ene Naisho - Member of the Naisho family, Leshuta, Kenya (Emonyorit Earring/necklace)
- Nollimesegel Ene Sulul - Member of the Sulul family, Morijo, Kenya (Isikira Necklace)
- Naipaa Olonyokie Laizer - Member of the Saiyialel family, Kimokouwa, Tanzania (Isurutia Ring-necklace)
- Kumari Nondikeya Laizer - Member of the Mbaima family, Loliondo, Tanzania (Orkataar Bracelet)
- Komesha Moseka Laizer - Member of the Moseka family, Kilimanjaro, Tanzania (Engononkoi Narok Blue beads necklace)
The delegates will be visiting from Sunday 22 September to Sunday 29 September 2024.
The 2024 delegation is a diverse group with five families' representatives and representatives from the Orkiaama, PALCA and Oltoilo le Maa, a community video collective in Tanzania. The family members were chosen as a result of the lineage research conducted in 2022/2023 of the family from which the artefact was taken. They are the rightful lineage or the heirs of the particular wing of the family. For the families whose artefact was worn by women, they chose a female delegate, and those whose artefact was for men chose a male delegate.
The Orkiaama delegates were chosen in the Orkiaama meeting on 1 April 2024 at the Maa nation Holy Land - Endonyo Oormoruaak. The traditional council of the Maa nation made the decision to choose two women, one from Tanzania and another from Kenya to represent the nation and to reflect their role as cultural custodians and the tact that women made all the artefacts in question. All the delegation members had the blessings of the Orkiaama, as the overall leadership council in the Maa nation. Mokompo, the spiritual leader, was also extensively consulted before the decisions were made by Orkiaama and the families. He gave his blessings and guidance, particularly on the rituals, events and overall framework of the visit.
The Pan African Living Cultures Alliance (PALCA) is an international NGO led by and for Indigenous Peoples of Africa and registered in Kenya. PALCA's mission is to safeguard communities' biocultural rights, support inter-generational transmission, preserve indigenous languages, promote traditional governance of natural resources, with participatory video at its heart. Currently PALCA only includes Maasai communities; however their hope is to build the alliance between more Indigenous communities nearby, such as the Sengwer and Ogiek, as well as beyond East Africa.
The Orkiaama is the Maasai's traditional leadership structure, which politically and culturally represents 1.2 million Maasai and was traditionally composed of a male representative from each of the 25 Maasai sections from Kenya and Tanzania. As part of the Living Cultures project, the Orkiaama, which had not met in 110 years, was reestablished for the 2023 visit to Kenya and Tanzania, where for each of the 2 sections, representations of one man and one woman assisted at the two opening healing ceremonies.
- The Pitt Rivers Museum
- The Staples Trust - a Sainsbury family charitable trust and project funder
- PALCA - The Pan-Africa Living Culture Alliance, an international organisation led by Maasai cultural leader and activist Samwel Nangiria
- Oltoila la Maa FM - a community-based participatory video group formed in Loliondo, Tanzania
The Pitt Rivers Museum has 95,327 objects from Africa, which include 9443 from Kenya and 2794 from Tanzania. Of these, 188 are attributed to the Maasai. The Maasai collection includes decorative and ceremonial objects and attire such as neck ornaments, a beadwork belt and a horn trumpet.
1. Engononkoi Narok - A hereditary necklace of blue beads passed from father to son, a crucial element of initiation ceremonies. It should never be sold or given away. (Accession number: 1904.34.25) Collector: Alfred Claud Hollis
2. Emonyorit - Earring worn by young women after circumcision, reconfigured into a neck ornament after marriage. It would never stay permanently in this state. (Accession number: 1904.34.36) Collector: Alfred Claud Hollis
3. Orkatar/Orkataar - Hereditary bracelet passed from father to son, which should never be sold or given away. (Accession number: 1904.34.38.1-2) Collector: Alfred Claud Hollis
4. Isikira - Head ornament worn by newly circumcised girls. It can only be used by one specific person and would always be dismantled after use. It can never be borrowed, sold or given away. (Accession number: 1927.84.51) Collector: Rev. William Ernest Taylor
5. Isrutia - Hereditary woman's arm/neck ornament which represents the sacred bond of marriage. It can never be borrowed, sold or given away. (Accession number: 1996.21.77) Collector: Phoebe Somers
The Pitt Rivers Museum acknowledges that objects in the collections were acquired through violence, looting and by the exertion of western colonial power on 'subject' people. We aim to work collectively with partners from across the world towards redress on a case-by-case basis. The Museum is committed to working with stakeholders and source communities to research the provenance of the collections, consider claims for restitution, and address historic museum practices which require change for the benefit of all our visitors and global community. Further information can be found at https://www.prm.ox.ac.uk/committed-to-change and https://www.glam.ox.ac.uk/procedures-for-return-of-cultural-objects-claims.
We have not received a claim for the return of these objects. The individual families will advise whether they want their family object to be returned home or to remain in the care of the Museum. The University has a formal process for any claim for the return of objects: https://www.glam.ox.ac.uk/procedures-for-return-of-cultural-objects-claims
If any claims for return were made, we would follow the established University Procedures.
The project will make meaningful, real-world impacts on Maasai people at a time when they are suffering due to land-rights issues and climate change. The project also enhances the Museum's knowledge and understanding of Maasai culture and history, which benefits online and on-site visitors who want to learn about the Maasai and indigenous cultures.
Timeline of the Project
- 2017 Visit of Samwel Nangiria and other indigenous leaders as part of the Indigenous Leadership Training Programme by InsightShare.
- 2018 Concern raised by elders of Loliondo (via video) and invitation to engage.
- 2018 First delegation of five Maasai representatives highlight five objects of concern (out of total of 188 objects) and identify other objects. This information is used to correct inaccurate records on database.
- 2019 Maasai delegates work with Chief Mokompo and Maa representatives to identify the best way forward.
- 2020 Second delegation of seven Maasai representatives, including Laibon Lemaron Ole Parit, visit Pitt Rivers Museum, Oxford, Horniman Museum, London and the Museum of Anthropology & Archaeology, Cambridge, to identify how (using Maasai systems of knowledge) the five objects of concern were brought here, which families are affected by their absence and what the possible ways of reconciliation are.
- 2020-2021 Reports by Mokompo on the possible ways forward for reconciliation, such as the Elata Oo Ngiro ceremony. A Radical Hope webinar provides a forum for open discussion on the options.
- 2020-2021 Work with Pitt Rivers Museum Learning Team and Assistant Researcher, Thandi Wilson, to make new educational materials, including handling objects and films.
- 2022 Next phase funding for pilgrimage by Maasai to affected families.
- 2023 Elata Oo Ngiro ceremony takes place in June/July led by PanAfrican Living Cultures Alliance (PALCA), which is responsible for running the ceremony, including the buying of the cows and all ritual and diplomatic parts of the process.
- 2024 A delegation of family representatives and representatives from the Orkiaama, PALCA and Oltoilo le Maa visit Pitt Rivers Museum to reconnect with the objects and decide on the next steps.
Press & Media